FWS v Scottish Ministers III – written submissions

Ahead of the judicial review of the Scottish Prison Service Policy for the Management of Transgender People in Custody being heard on 3rd – 5th February 2026 in the Court of Session, we are now able to publish our written submissions.


Petition – For Women Scotland

Aidan O’Neill KC and Tony Convery, Advocate
Submitted 12 December 2025

Note of Argument – For Women Scotland

Aidan O’Neill KC and Tony Convery, Advocate
Submitted 15 December 2025

AffidavitRhona Hotchkiss

Submitted 15 December 2025

One of the productions we submitted to the court is the analysis by MurrayBlackburnMackenzie: Why does the Scottish Prison Service hold men convicted of murder in the female prison estate? A policy timeline, which is essential background reading for the evolution of the prison policy and the men who have been housed in female prisons.


The Scottish Ministers have published the following submissions:

The written submissions from the two interveners are also available: